Wilson Mutual is a member of Motorists Insurance Group. Since 1872, quality service has become a habit. Wilson Mutual Fire In ... surance Company was born when schoolteacher Peter Schneider met with a group of pioneer settlers in a little red schoolhouse near Six Corners. The new settlers were looking for a way to protect their growing assets and Peter Schneider had the idea of how to provide the protection they needed at the best possible cost. He would incorporate this small group of people to better serve their common needs. And so began a long history of providing quality service and innovative insurance products to policyholders and independent agents. Service starts with people, and ours are some of the best in the business. We pride ourselves in providing superior customer service, outstanding claims service, and having a team of professionally trained independent agents bent on helping our customers find the right insurance products. To us, "Our People Make the Difference" is more than a company slogan, it’s the secret of our success. Our Vision Wilson Mutual Insurance Company will be the best choice possible for its policyholders, agents, and associates." Operating states Wilson Mutual writes business in Minnesota and Wisconsin. read more