Crosby's Stores had its beginnings as a dairy farm founded in 1902 by E. S. O'Mara. E. S. grew the farm and by 1940 opened hi ... s first dairy bar in a newly constructed milk plant. In 1965, the O'Mara Dairy Farm merged with Crosby Dairy. On July 1st, 1966, Crosby Dairy opened its first store in Little Valley, New York. Our first gas pump opened in 1972, a single bay gas station acquired from the Kendall Refining Corporation located in Bradford. By 1996 we developed a food service program that continues to be the focus of our future vision today. In 2006, Crosby's Stores was acquired by Reid Stores, of Lockport, NY, where it was merged with K&K Foods and the chain was re branded Crosby's Stores. Most of all, along the way, we emphasized the importance of customer service. Serving rural communities with our roots as a family dairy business, we strive to be the hometown presence with a personal touch for each and every customer. That's why we've made our tagline "Add a Smile to your day!" read more